Review l2ThwQQJw2C7 · published 2026-11-10 17:58:15
No reports.
What worked well
Good sermons, good accounting and stewardship of the church’s financial resources
What a newcomer should know
Father Simon is standoffish to new parishioners. Social interaction is not his strong point. However, I will note the people in the parish are for the most part welcoming and warm to newcomers. Do not expect a timely response if you reach out to him with an issue.
Context
Father Simon Thomas is an intelligent, knowledgeable priest with considerable strengths in theology, preaching, and parish administration. Some of his sermons are genuinely outstanding, offering thoughtful and meaningful reflections on the Orthodox faith. He is also an exceptionally capable administrator, particularly regarding parish finances and the organization of major events such as the Greek Festival. His organizational abilities are a real asset to the parish. Unfortunately, his strengths in these areas do not always translate into effective pastoral leadership. Father Simon can seem distant and difficult to approach on a personal level. During several years of attending the parish, an invitation for him and his wife to visit our home was declined, and no effort was made to arrange an alternative time. While a single declined invitation would ordinarily be unremarkable, the absence of any subsequent effort to connect reinforced an impression of limited personal pastoral engagement. More concerning is what appears to be a reluctance to address difficult interpersonal situations directly. His approach can give the impression that avoiding confrontation takes precedence over resolving underlying problems. While maintaining peace within a parish is important, genuine peace sometimes requires uncomfortable conversations, clear boundaries, and decisive leadership. A priest need not be extroverted or naturally sociable to be an effective spiritual father. However, parishioners should feel that their concerns will be heard and that difficult situations will be addressed with compassion, fairness, and appropriate firmness. Father Simon possesses genuine gifts as a theologian, preacher, and administrator. Yet the priesthood is fundamentally a pastoral vocation. Financial stability, successful festivals, and excellent sermons, while important, cannot replace personal engagement and the willingness to shepherd parishioners through challenging circumstances. Overall, Father Simon has considerable strengths, but his ministry would benefit from greater personal accessibility, more proactive pastoral care, and a willingness to address difficult situations rather than allowing them to remain unresolved.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction