Pastoral care★★★★★
Teaching & preaching★★★★★
Intelligence★★★★★
Social skills★★★★★
Accessibility★★★★★
Newcomer friendliness★★★★★
Communication★★★★★
Liturgical leadership★★★★★
Practice & orientation
Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.
Ascetical strictness2.7
LenientDemanding
Political extremism1.3
None seenSevere
Reports
Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.
Bullying1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
Appropriate behavior and relations1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Firsthand reviews
★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review H9gb6ZtQ65hh · published 2026-11-04 23:50:47
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Fr. Michael is a wonderful priest. Excellent at one-on-one care and a strong leader.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review uhe2HzPR3Glm · published 2026-10-19 21:34:19
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Fr. Michael is friendly, engaging, and committed to Christ and his role as Priest, and spiritual father. He takes time to listen and carefully sort through things that are brought to his attention, and works together well with the Parish Council. He is attentive to the needs of the parish and a faithful steward of Christ. He is a solid and fair leader.
What a newcomer should know
Do not worry about approaching Fr. Michael; he is warm and friendly, and very demonstrative of the Love of Christ to whoever he meets.
Context
I attend regularly and am involved in several areas of ministry within the church. I would not be where I am spiritually without his help and guidance. The Lord truly brought me to St. Michael's and I am grateful to be here and serve in the capacities I serve in. We are blessed to have Fr. Michael as our shepherd!
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review q_0_LWIwhKl6 · published 2026-10-07 22:40:31
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Fr Michael guided me through my Cancer Journey. He helped me to keep my faith through troubling times. The prayers and blessings gave me the strength to overcome Cancer. Fr Michael is a true Priest and Leader of his Parishioners near and far. We need more of these kind of Priests to gather the flock and lead them to our Heavenly Father. God bless him.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review W8WZFhfj0oD8 · published 2026-10-06 12:43:04
No reports.
What a newcomer should know
I travel for work & have had the pleasure of visiting St. Michael’s Orthodox Church in Old Forge PA & meeting Fr. Michael Shepherd & his lovely parish. I had only been going to Orthodox churches for a few months & was always very nervous to visit new ones. But after walking through the front door I found nothing but love. Fr. Michael himself welcomed us personally, & once he had to go, multiple others followed in his footsteps & showed me the same love & kindness he did. Fr. Michael is a strong leader of his parish, from the Liturgy to coffee hour, he is present & attentive. His firm foundation in leadership & character, (which he shares with his lovely wife) is infectious in the church & you can find pieces of his unwavering dedication to God & love for others in every person, & in every corner of the church.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review irUFePDoeoMo · published 2026-10-06 04:17:02
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Father Michael genuinely cares for all of his parishioners. He's a good man and always is willing to listen and help someone as much as he can. We're very blessed to have him here at St. Michael's!
What a newcomer should know
Father Michael is very friendly and always willing to talk to any newcomers. Don't be afraid to say hello and inquire about anything.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review qqGJzcw8ZYvO · published 2026-10-06 01:00:57
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Fr Michael has been our priest for the last five years and since he came here our parish grew. He brought life back to the church.We are so blessed to have him and his family .
What a newcomer should know
Fr Michael is a very warm and kind hearted person he always go out of his way to welcome any newcomers and takes the time to talk to them.
Context
I've been going to this parish for over 50 years and it has changed it's very warm and loving place all thanks to Fr Michael and his family.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 0qRBmrsLXPqJ · published 2026-10-06 01:00:27
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
I have never seen a man so dedicated. I don’t have first hand experience with priests, but if someone told me they were worried about not fitting in I’d tell them not to worry because Fr Michael wouldn’t allow it.
What a newcomer should know
Know that he is probably the definition of wanting you to push further, but letting you decide when to move forward. You will never feel pressured with him unless you ask him be that kind of mentor, but the pursuit of knowledge will almost certainly need come from individual as catechesis is still a developing process, but that doesn’t mean the knowledge isn’t readily available.
Context
I’ve been attending for almost a year now and increasingly so since I first started going. As a catechumen I haven’t felt the most welcoming place I’ve ever been to.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction