← Directory

Orthodox Church in America

Rev. Matthew Mcdonald

Clergy at St. Michael the Archangel Church · Saint Louis, MO

3.01 published review

Community ratings

Write a review
Pastoral care★★★☆☆
Teaching & preaching★★★★☆
Intelligence★★★★☆
Social skills★★☆☆☆
Accessibility★★☆☆☆
Newcomer friendliness★★☆☆☆
Communication★★☆☆☆
Liturgical leadership★★★★★

Practice & orientation

Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.

Ascetical strictness4.0
LenientDemanding
Ecumenism1.0
ClosedOpen
Political extremism2.0
None seenSevere

Reports

Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.

Bullying1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
Appropriate behavior and relations1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level

These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Firsthand reviews

★★★☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score

Review jicq4QqvtQfT · published 2026-10-04 19:32:16

Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

What worked well

Allowed a group of right wing parishioners and catachumans to brigade and bully out a beloved gay parishioner serving on the Altar. A former Catachuman named Stanton Brown killed themself in front of the church.

What a newcomer should know

He knows a lot about the ministry for the poor, and runs a tight ship, liturgically speaking, but is generally unfriendly and standoffish, and finds it difficult to make time for pastoral care for parishioners

Context

From December 2025, to June 2026, we went from about 80 people on any given Sunday to 30. It's been a disastrous year, and it may kill the church.

Respond to this review · Report or request correction