← Directory

Orthodox Church in America

Rev. Joseph Birthisel

Clergy at St. Cyprian of Carthage Church · Midlothian, VA

1.01 published review

Community ratings

Write a review
Pastoral care★☆☆☆☆
Teaching & preaching★★★☆☆
Intelligence★★★☆☆
Social skills★☆☆☆☆
Accessibility★☆☆☆☆
Newcomer friendliness★★☆☆☆
Communication★☆☆☆☆
Liturgical leadership★★★☆☆

Practice & orientation

Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.

Ascetical strictness3.0
LenientDemanding
Ecumenism1.0
ClosedOpen
Political extremism4.0
None seenSevere

Reports

Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.

Bullying5.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
Appropriate behavior and relations5.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level

These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Firsthand reviews

★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score

Review RTkevHLzrUkS · published 2026-11-11 14:25:09

Bullying: reviewer’s original score 5/5.

Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 5/5.

Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Former parishionerat Christ the Saviour Mission StationLast attended 2026

What a newcomer should know

This priest and his dean abruptly banned my wife and me after we contacted the dean to discuss sincere concerns about the priest’s ability to provide pastoral care. We withdrew our request before raising any specific concerns, yet the dean issued the ban immediately by email, relying solely on the priest’s testimony. We were given no opportunity to respond. We were barred from the mission station we founded and primarily funded, and we were threatened with arrest and excommunication. The priest and the dean then went silent. During the mission station’s first five months, we gave about $30,000, roughly 80% of its contributions. About $14,000 of that came just weeks before the ban. The priest had been privately raising concerns about the mission’s viability, and we wanted to reassure him that he had solid financial support. Please pray that the Holy Spirit will bring him to repentance and restore him to the Gospel.

Context

We had known this priest for more than six years at two parishes and encouraged him regularly throughout that time.

Respond to this review · Report or request correction