Pastoral care★★☆☆☆
Teaching & preaching★★☆☆☆
Intelligence★★★★☆
Social skills★★★★☆
Accessibility★★☆☆☆
Newcomer friendliness★★★☆☆
Communication★★☆☆☆
Liturgical leadership★★☆☆☆
Practice & orientation
Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.
Ascetical strictness3.7
LenientDemanding
Political extremism2.8
None seenSevere
Reports
Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.
Bullying2.5
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
Appropriate behavior and relations3.5
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Firsthand reviews
★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review bl1ClpZcHWxW · published 2026-11-03 19:34:04
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 4/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 5/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
Nothing unless you are there to worship Father John instead of Christ.
What a newcomer should know
One commenter said that they have heard Fr John referred to as Saint John. This is because he is basically a cult leader, and if you are not part of his cult, you are persona non grata, and he will go out of his way to harass you. He has demanded that parishioners be obedient only to him or they are not welcome in the church.
Context
I attended regularly for over a decade, and have personally witnessed Fr John harassing parishioners, other clergy, and other parishes that did not bend the knee to him.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score
Review nKdpT5gk4My8 · published 2026-11-02 14:44:52
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
He’s there alot, might as well live at the church. And he’s always open to conversation as long as he’s not in the middle of a service.
What a newcomer should know
Some have referred to him as Saint John. I don’t know about that but I do know that he loves his neighbor like no other person I’ve met.
Context
I attend regularly and since I’ve started going to Saint a Mary’s I will say that old age is doing its part to Fr. John. His memory is getting worse and sometimes he gets cranky. However I am under the impression that he is an amazing minister and role model.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review HNdt_PmBKCpi · published 2026-10-09 19:00:23
No reports.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 9echtz-3GZZY · published 2026-10-08 19:02:53
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 4/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 4/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review NqDTJN23hbOT · published 2026-10-07 02:20:48
No reports.
What worked well
It’s a large enough parish with busy enough people that you might not realize that Fr John has basically set himself up as a cult leader who gets very angry if he does not get everything he wants when he wants it.
What a newcomer should know
There are several other local parishes that are not cults
Context
I have been a parishioner for several years but will be leaving for a real parish instead of being part of the cult.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 0IwMFpyqZ1jX · published 2026-10-06 15:35:08
Bullying: score withheld by moderation.
Appropriate behavior and relations: score withheld by moderation.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review KSdw4RbxCAcJ · published 2026-10-06 04:18:05
Appropriate behavior and relations: score withheld by moderation.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review juMWbnpgwjrC · published 2026-10-05 17:29:54
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.
Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 4/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Context
He is frilly involved in the Matthew Williams scandal, and has been covering for him since the beginning
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★★☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review TJP916LrBNVv · published 2026-10-03 23:52:25
No reports.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction