← Directory

Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia

Priest Jeremiah Davis

Clergy,Cleric at St. Matrona of Moscow Mission · Winchester, KY

3.02 published reviews

Community ratings

Write a review
Pastoral care★★★☆☆
Teaching & preaching★★★☆☆
Intelligence★★★★☆
Social skills★★★★☆
Accessibility★★★★☆
Newcomer friendliness★★★★★
Communication★★★★☆
Liturgical leadership★★★★☆

Practice & orientation

Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.

Ascetical strictness4.0
LenientDemanding
Ecumenism1.5
ClosedOpen
Political extremism2.5
None seenSevere

Reports

Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.

Bullying1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
Appropriate behavior and relations1.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level

These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Firsthand reviews

★★★★★ Reviewer’s overall score

Review um1DM_d1N_BC · published 2026-10-09 22:11:48

Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Other firsthand interactionat St. Matrona of Moscow MissionLast attended 2026

What worked well

Fr. Jeremiah is an excellent priest. He is extraordinarily pastoral, cares deeply about his parishioners, and works tirelessly around the clock to help people with their spiritual problems. I am not ROCOR myself, but I have had a fair bit of experience with ROCOR parishes over the couple of decades I have been Orthodox, and I can say that while Fr. Jeremiah is a bit more strict than my tradition, he is one of the most pastoral and accommodating priests within the Slavic tradition. Yes, everything he does is by the book. But he's always willing to explain and educate. The rapid growth of his parish is a testament to his work ethic, and his compassion for his flock.

What a newcomer should know

He's always available to talk. ROCOR is often a bit more strict than most other jurisdictions, but he is always willing to explain the meaning behind the rules.

Context

I've visited here and there throughout the past several years. It's a very nice community. Not a member.

Respond to this review · Report or request correction
★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score

Review cp5pTpmCkNJM · published 2026-10-02 19:19:05

Bullying: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Appropriate behavior and relations: reviewer’s original score 1/5.

Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.

Former parishionerat St. Matrona of Moscow MissionLast attended 2025

What worked well

Very friendly to newcomers and visitors.

What a newcomer should know

My experience was primarily negative. The best description of my parish experience would be "cult like". Initially, it was not like this, but over time Fr Jeremiah became increasingly overbearing and controlling. I would describe it as spiritual abuse. He required parishioners to inform him of our whereabouts on Sundays if we missed liturgy. He introduced novel liturgical and sacramental rules that, when I asked another priest in ROCOR about, he informed me that these were not ROCOR practices but stricter innovations, such as confession required within 72 hours of communion rather than within the last week. When asked by a visitor about one of these novel practices, I was honest and explained that the practice was a preference of the priest's and not something they'd likely see elsewhere. Fr Jeremiah confronted me later and told me to "Stop disparaging the Russian tradition", despite the liturgical novelties in question not being a part of the Russian liturgical tradition. Sermons toward the end became increasingly centered on total obedience to one's parish priest without question. In one instance, he gave a short sermon in front of other parishioners present about how I embarrassed him by arriving late for Vigil, in order to have confession, due to my work schedule which he was informed of many months prior. I eventually began being less present and attending other parishes while visiting family. During this time, Fr Jeremiah accused me of substance abuse and addiction due to a rumor started by an irregular visitor, and instructed me to cut off all contact with my family due to my father occasionally drinking alcohol, and to cut off all contact with my friends due to them saying swear words. I also struggle with depression and suicidal ideation, and at the guidance of my former monastic spiritual father, I sought out an Orthodox therapist. Fr Jeremiah instructed me to stop seeing my therapist when making the substance abuse allegations and stated that my mental illness struggles were "spiritual in nature and happening because [I] was not praying and going to church enough", despite my intense prayer rule prescribed by my former spiritual father, regular church attendance, and involvement in parish life. As a result of these extreme commands, I decided to leave the parish before the conversation had even ended. After my departure, I started received a text message from my monastic spiritual father, and I spoke with him on the phone about the situation. He explained Fr Jeremiah had contacted him asking for my whereabouts, and my SF became worried about me and contacted me. I explained the situation, and upon explaining what I was told about cutting off family and stopping therapy, he loudly reacted "HE SAID WHAT?", and he then told me that I made the right decision and to "never go back there".

Context

I served liturgically in the altar and choir. Most of these things happened progressively over the course of multiple years. I had a monastic spiritual father at a nearby monastery but due to unforseen circumstances he could no longer serve as my confessor. We are still on good terms and talk periodically.

Respond to this review · Report or request correction