Pastoral care★☆☆☆☆
Teaching & preaching★★☆☆☆
Intelligence★★☆☆☆
Social skills★★★☆☆
Accessibility★☆☆☆☆
Newcomer friendliness★★★☆☆
Communication★★☆☆☆
Liturgical leadership★★☆☆☆
Practice & orientation
Descriptive spectrums—neither end is scored as better.
Ascetical strictness2.0
LenientDemanding
Political extremism5.0
None seenSevere
Reports
Reviewer ratings, separate from the overall score.
Bullying5.0
Reviewer: no concerns seenReviewer: highest concern level
These are contributor reports and opinions. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
Firsthand reviews
★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 9KMJiC3TuJkU · published 2026-11-04 07:21:35
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 5/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
It’s a large enough parish with busy people that you might not realize that Fr James has basically set himself up as a cult leader who gets very angry if he does not get everything he wants when he wants it.
What a newcomer should know
He cares only about himself, his family and the major donors.
The donors are being rewarded with exclusive access to knowledge about parishioners, tactics to sabotage others while in church.
Every time someone executes his dirty deeds, the person gets recognition and in some cases they become nominees for the parish council.
Context
Fr James is accessible based on the amount of contributions provided. This is a serious matter!
He becomes extremely uncomfortable when it is about accountability.
He has no problem harassing parishioners including children. yES!!!! Children!
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review BU0qtxQ5a55Y · published 2026-10-14 17:54:48
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 5/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
This priest needs to understand that churches are not HOAs, country clubs or any other exclusive clubs. The same way that the kingdom of god is not an exclusive country club.
You can help the flock by doing the right thing- as a priest you should never allow bullying or exploit the vulnerable people.
Your willingness to put money above the church’s teachings is deeply concerning
What a newcomer should know
Save your soul!
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 4zbabpnDTyv9 · published 2026-10-12 12:33:44
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 5/5. Moderator display adjustment: 3/5 (not the reviewer’s rating).
Appropriate behavior and relations: score withheld by moderation.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
He comes across as easy going. Extremely friendly with the parishioners that share the Lebanese heritage. Distant and rigid with all other ethnicities ( unless he has a special interest)
What a newcomer should know
He is a good salesman
Context
James shadid would do himself a favor if he would go work for Trump. He has a proven record of catering to the people that he perceives as “ important to keep his job”. Everyone else does not matter.
This man needs to see the log in his eye before looking at the spec in his brother’s: sister’s eye.
Do not make the mistake of thinking that he cares about your salvation. As shocking as it might sound, certain parishioners are tasked with stalking their own sister and brother in Christ …… yes- I am not aware of the Bible allowing stalking and harassment against one another.
Save your soul! I do hope that the leadership of AOC makes note of this concern.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction★☆☆☆☆ Reviewer’s overall score
Review 9j73WDDPekWB · published 2026-10-05 12:08:52
Bullying: reviewer’s original score 5/5.
Scores report this reviewer’s experience. Publication is not a finding of misconduct, truth or safety.
What worked well
James shadid as described by some of the regulars is “ one of the boys”. He is friendly only to the people that he likes aka “ regular church donors”
What a newcomer should know
In the beginning he appears to be friendly. However, a newcomer should expect to become a stalker for the people that are not liked by him.
He has a strong sense of pleasing the major donors …… and the rest do not matter.
His favorite hypocrisy “ forgive me” and he turns around and “ stabs you behind your back”
Context
People have been forced out of the church with his knowledge. He allows church politics to run his decisions. Truthfully, a priest should guide souls to salvation not to the exit door.
I have witnessed several instances where some of his inner circle people acted cowardly towards some people that he disliked .
I prefer to come to this site to voice my concerns because I doubt that the AOC leadership will coach him.
Respond to this review · Report or request correction